Test prehliadacov: IE, FF, Opera, Chrome, Safari, Maxthon..

Testovana zostava:

Toshiba Satellite A200-1M8
C2D T7100 1.8GHz 2MB L2
Mobility Radeon HD2600 256MB DDR2
2x2GB Kingston 800MHz CL5
160GB Hitachi 5400ot. 8MB cache
Windows 7.057 x64

Pri tomto teste som vychadzal z volne dostupnych benchmarkov zalozenych na javascript,
testery kompatibility pocitaju s podporou HTML 4 a CSS standardov.

Testovane prehliadace:

IE 8.0.7057 (sucast Windows 7)
IE 8.0.7057 x64 (sucast Windows 7)
Maxthon 2.5.1.4751 (based on IE7)

Firefox 3.0.10
Firefox 3.5 Beta 4
Minefield 3.0.7 (Firefox x64)
Minefield 3.2 Alpha1 (Firefox x64)

Opera 9.64
Opera 10 Alpha (1139)

Google Chrome 1.0.154.48
Google Chrome 2.0.169.1 Beta

Safari 3.2.2 (525.28.1) for Windows
Safari 4 Beta (528.16) for Windows


Testy kompatibility:

1. Acid 1 http://www.w3.org/Style/CSS/Test/CSS1/c ... t5526c.htm

Prvy a najstarsi z tychto testov a kedze ho kazdy z testovanych prehliadacov zvladol bez chyby, vysledok je spolocny:



2. Acid 2 http://www.webstandards.org/files/acid2/test.html

Referencny, spravny vysledok by mal vyzerat takto:


Spravny vysledok sa podaril kazdemu prehliadacu, okrem Maxthon-a. V jeho pripade dopadol test takto:




3. Acid 3 http://acid3.acidtests.org/

Najnovsi zo serie Acid testov, v dnesnej dobe sa mu priklada najvacsi doraz. Hodnoti sa, ako daleko sa v teste dostane prehliadac a boduje sa od 0 do 100. 100/100 je teda maximum, avsak nemusi hned znamenat splnenie testu, ako uvidime dalej.

IE 8.0.7057 x86 & x64:


Maxthon 2.5.1:


Firefox 3.0.7 & Minefield 3.0.7:


Firefox 3.1 Beta 3, Firefox 3.5 Beta 4 & Minefield 3.2 Alpha 1:


Opera 9.64:


Opera 10 Alpha 1:


Chrome:


Chrome 2 Beta:


Safari 3.2.2:


Safari 4 Beta:



Testy rychlosti:

1. SunSpider JavaScript Benchmark: http://www2.webkit.org/perf/sunspider-0 ... pider.html (menej ms = rychlejsi)

IE 8.0.7057 - Total: 6599.6 ms +/- 1.6%
IE 8.0.7057 x64 - Total: 5964.2 ms +/- 0.7%
Maxthon 2.5.1 - Total: 7376.0 ms +/- 1.8%

Firefox 3.0.7 - Total: 4411.4 ms +/- 4.6%
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - Total: 2494.6 ms +/- 7.8%
Minefield 3.0.7 - Total: 5200.2 ms +/- 2.7%
Minefield 3.2 Alpha 1 - Total: 3632.2 ms +/- 4.6%

Opera 9.64 - Total: 6002.0 ms +/- 1.9%
Opera 10 Alpha - Total: 4569.8 ms +/- 2.0%

Google Chrome - Total: 2017.8 ms +/- 7.6%
Google Chrome 2 Beta - Total: 1322.6 ms +/- 4.8%

Safari 3.2.2 - Total: 5354.4 ms +/- 3.0%
Safari 4 Beta - Total: 1804.8 ms +/- 5.9%

Zoradene od najrychlejsieho po najpomalsi:

Google Chrome 2 Beta - Total: 1322.6 ms +/- 4.8%
Safari 4 Beta - Total: 1804.8 ms +/- 5.9%
Google Chrome - Total: 2017.8 ms +/- 7.6%
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - Total: 2494.6 ms +/- 7.8%
Minefield 3.2 Alpha 1 - Total: 3632.2 ms +/- 4.6%
Firefox 3.0.7 - Total: 4411.4 ms +/- 4.6%
Opera 10 Alpha - Total: 4569.8 ms +/- 2.0%
Minefield 3.0.7 - Total: 5200.2 ms +/- 2.7%
Safari 3.2.2 - Total: 5354.4 ms +/- 3.0%
IE 8.0.7057 x64 - Total: 5964.2 ms +/- 0.7%
Opera 9.64 - Total: 6002.0 ms +/- 1.9%
IE 8.0.7057 - Total: 6599.6 ms +/- 1.6%
Maxthon 2.5.1 - Total: 7376.0 ms +/- 1.8%


2. Dromaeo JavaScript Performance Testing: http://dromaeo.com/ (Recommended Tests; viac runs/s = rychlejsi)

IE 8.0.7057 - Failed
IE 8.0.7057 x64 - Failed
Maxthon 2.5.1 - Failed

Firefox 3.0.7 - Performance Tests 36.12 runs/s (Total)
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - Performance Tests 59.33 runs/s (Total)
Minefield 3.0.7 - Performance Tests 29.80 runs/s (Total)
Minefield 3.2 Alpha 1 - Performance Tests 42.03 runs/s (Total)

Opera 9.64 - Performance Tests 21.72 runs/s (Total)
Opera 10 Alpha - Performance Tests 37.17 runs/s (Total)

Google Chrome - Performance Tests 74.96 runs/s (Total)
Google Chrome 2 Beta - Performance Tests 96.72 runs/s (Total)

Safari 3.2.2 - Performance Tests 38.02 runs/s (Total)
Safari 4 Beta - Performance Tests 108.14 runs/s (Total)

Zoradene od najrychlejsieho po najpomalsi:

Safari 4 Beta - Performance Tests 108.14 runs/s (Total)
Google Chrome 2 Beta - Performance Tests 96.72 runs/s (Total)
Google Chrome - Performance Tests 74.96 runs/s (Total)
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - Performance Tests [color=orange]59.33 runs/s (Total)
Minefield 3.2 Alpha 1 - Performance Tests 42.03 runs/s (Total)
Safari 3.2.2 - Performance Tests 38.02 runs/s (Total)
Opera 10 Alpha - Performance Tests 37.17 runs/s (Total)
Firefox 3.0.7 - Performance Tests 36.12 runs/s (Total)
Minefield 3.0.7 - Performance Tests 29.80 runs/s (Total)
Opera 9.64 - Performance Tests 21.72 runs/s (Total)
IE 8.0.7057 - Failed
IE 8.0.7057 x64 - Failed
Maxthon 2.5.1 - Failed


3. Futuremark Peacekeeper Beta: http://service.futuremark.com/peacekeeper/index.action (viac = rychlejsi)

IE 8.0.7057 - 274 Points
IE 8.0.7057 x64 - 301 Points
Maxthon 2.5.1 - 244 Points

Firefox 3.0.7 - 361 Points
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - 553 Points
Minefield 3.0.7 - 291 Points
Minefield 3.2 Alpha 1 - 534 Points

Opera 9.64 - 439 Points
Opera 10 Alpha - 681 Points

Google Chrome - 543 Points
Google Chrome 2 Beta - 623 Points

Safari 3.2.2 - 663 Points
Safari 4 Beta - 956 Points

Zoradene od najrychlejsieho po najpomalsi:

Safari 4 Beta - 956 Points
Opera 10 Alpha - 681 Points
Safari 3.2.2 - 663 Points
Google Chrome 2 Beta - 623 Points
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - 553 Points
Google Chrome - 543 Points
Minefield 3.2 Alpha 1 - 534 Points
Opera 9.64 - 439 Points
Firefox 3.0.7 - 361 Points
IE 8.0.7057 x64 - 301 Points
Minefield 3.0.7 - 291 Points
IE 8.0.7057 - 274 Points
Maxthon 2.5.1 - 244 Points


4. V8 Benchmark Suite - version 3: http://v8.googlecode.com/svn/data/bench ... 3/run.html (viac = rychlejsi)

IE 8.0.7057 - Score: 74.0
IE 8.0.7057 x64 - Score: 77.8
Maxthon 2.5.1 - Score: 72.8

Firefox 3.0.7 - Score: 160
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - Score: 210
Minefield 3.0.7 - Score: 120
Minefield 3.2 Alpha 1 - Score: 166

Opera 9.64 - Score: 160
Opera 10 Alpha - Score: 178

Google Chrome - Score: 1446
Google Chrome 2 Beta - Score: 1968

Safari 3.2.2 - Score: 145
Safari 4 Beta - Score: 1328

Zoradene od najrychlejsieho po najpomalsi:

Google Chrome 2 Beta - Score: 1968
Google Chrome - Score: 1446
Safari 4 Beta - Score: 1328
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - Score: 210
Opera 10 Alpha - Score: 178
Minefield 3.2 Alpha 1 - Score: 166
Opera 9.64 - Score: 160
Firefox 3.0.7 - Score: 160
Safari 3.2.2 - Score: 145
Minefield 3.0.7 - Score: 120
IE 8.0.7057 x64 - Score: 77.8
IE 8.0.7057 - Score: 74.0
Maxthon 2.5.1 - Score: 72.8

Ak vas nieco napadne co by som mohol doplnit, prosim.

skús Slimbrowser. je to nadstavba IE6. skús preventívne aj IE7 (čoby default u visty) IE6 (čoby default u XP)

ie6 mi totiž failol všetky testy okrem acid 1

Mám otázku. Kde robím chybu keď mi FF 3.0.7 neprejde správne Acid2 testom??

Tak to neviem teda, acid2 test dnes spravi kazdy browser okrem IE6 a IE7 (Maxthon). IE7 aj IE6 som planoval zahrnut do testu, avsak windows 7 mi ho nedovoli regulerne nainstalovat. Ale ak je zaujem, poobzeram sa po portable verziach, s tym by problem nemal byt, minimalne o IE7 viem. Nahadzovat kvoli tomu vistu ci XP sa mi naozaj nechce, no niekde by som tu mal mat USB s live XP, tak tam to skusit mozem, avsak testy prebehnu pod inym OS prostredim, co je potrebne trosku zohladnit.

ie7 mi práve failol acid 2 a acid 3 a to tak zle že 5 bodov zo sto.

Tak ja som testol moj Firefox 3.0.7 a v Futuremark Peacekeeper Beta som mal 630 bodov a ty tam mas iba 361 tak to sa mi nezda

Žeby si mal CPU na 3,34GHz?

Spirit - mne Chrome 2 Beta spravil Acid3 na tri rozne vysledky - 97, 99 a 100 - vo vsetkych troch pripadoch napisalo fail, co je zaujimave...

Citame, uvazujeme a az potom piseme

eXi o tom paradoxe Chrome2 viem, mne prebehne vzdy na 100/100 ale FAIL, spolubyvajucemu na viste striedavo 99/100 a 100/100 opat FAIL. Tak ci onak, prehliadac test nesplnil, to ze dostal 100/100 nic neznamena.

IE7 je v teste zahrnuty - Maxthon

ten futuremark hodnoti na konkretnej zostave, ja som mal napr opera cca 300 a ff cca 400 a kamarat mal opera cca 500, firefox cca 300 a chrome cca 900 (zaukruhlene na stovky lebo presne cisla si nepamatam, merali sme to asi pred tyzdnom) - neviem akym sposobom to je merane, zalezi aj na aktualnej rychlosti pripojenia na internet?

Nie, stiahne sa ti java aplikacia a vykonava jednotlive testy. Testuje sa v 5 kategoriach a score je celkovym vysledkom ciastkovych testov (tak ako v 3dmarkoch). Vysledne skore zalezi iba na dvoch veciach - rychlost CPU a rychlost prehliadaca.

Davam do pozornosti novu Betu Firefoxu, presnejsie 3.5 Beta 4 (pokracovanie 3.1 Beta 3), link na stiahnutie v prvom prispevku. Prehnal som ho testami, kompatibilita sa zhoduje s predchodcom 3.1 Beta 3, Acid3 na 93/100.

Rychlostne testy:

1. SunSpider JavaScript Benchmark:

Firefox 3.0.7 - Total: 4411.4 ms
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - Total: 2494.6 ms
Firefox 3.5 Beta 4 - Total: 1752.2ms

pekne zrychlenie!

2. Dromaeo JavaScript Performance Testing:

Firefox 3.0.7 - Performance Tests 36.12 runs/s (Total)
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - Performance Tests 59.33 runs/s (Total)
Firefox 3.5 Beta 4 - Performance Tests 44.97runs/s (Total)

mierne spomalenie

3. Futuremark Peacekeeper Beta:

Firefox 3.0.7 - 361 Points
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - 553 Points
Firefox 3.5 Beta 4 - 499 Points

opat mierne spomalenie

4. V8 Benchmark Suite - version 3:

Firefox 3.0.7 - Score: 160
Firefox 3.1 Beta 3 - Score: 210
Firefox 3.5 Beta 4 - Score: 162

Skoda, aj tu sa rychlost vratila k 3.0.7

Doporucujem vsak vyskusat, prehliadac konecne cache-uje do RAM a celkovo je natahovanie web stranok blikacka (na dobrom nete) podobne ako v opere alebo safari.

Spirit ako je na tom beta FF so stabilitou?? Odporučil by si ju ako hlavný browser??

Pouzivam ho 2 dni, co je prilis kratka doba na hodnotenie, ale zatial sme so spolubyvajucim neobjavili problematicku stranku.

Opera 10 Beta (čerstvo vnútená )

stiahol som, nainštaloval a Acid 3. 100/100 Passol úplne dokonale. aj web "service.futuremark.com" sa zobrazuje korektne.

ja nic len ze mne to zakazdym dalo 100/100/100/100 a po 5 krat 100

chrome 2 určite, ten dával acidko na 100vku, ale BETA blbla

ale ja mam betu...ci pockat sak minule som to stahovala a aj tu je napisane google chrome 2 beta asi mam v tom zmatok

nieje to náhodou chrome 3 beta? Pretože dvojka je už prakticky postaršia...

//resp. dokonca chorme 4 beta

no tak to ti ja neviem teda pise mi tu,ze ma novu verziu tak teda 3 asi

Spravil som z nudy niektore testy na Firefox 3.5.3, Google Chrome 3.0.195.21, IE 7.0.5730.13

PC zostava: AMD Sempron 3300+, 1GB DDRAM, 250GB disk,
Prikladam aj vysledok speedmetra na jednotlivych prehliadačoch http://speedmeter.sk/
Meranie cez prehliadač:

IE 7.0.5730.13
Rýchlosť prijímania dát (download): 2638 kB/s ( 21,1 Mbps )
Rýchlosť odosielania dát (upload): 1113 kB/s ( 8904 kbps )

Firefox 3.5.3
Rýchlosť prijímania dát (download): 2825 kB/s ( 22,6 Mbps )
Rýchlosť odosielania dát (upload) : 1191 kB/s ( 9528 kbps )

Google Chrome 3.0.195.21
Rýchlosť prijímania dát (download):2229 kB/s( 17,8 Mbps )
Rýchlosť odosielania dát (upload) :966,2 kB/s( 7730 kbps )

Testy rychlosti:

1. SunSpider JavaScript Benchmark: http://www2.webkit.org/perf/sunspider-0 ... pider.html (menej ms = rychlejsi)

IE 7.0.5730.13 - Total: 94885.6ms +/- 4.6% (only one test)
Firefox 3.5.3 - Total: 2567,2 ms +/- 20,5%
Google Chrome 3.0.195.21 - Total: 950,6 ms +/- 9,95%

2. Futuremark Peacekeeper Beta: http://service.futuremark.com/peacekeeper/index.action (viac = rychlejsi)

IE 7.0.5730.13 - 289 Points
Firefox 3.5.3 - 1230 Points
Google Chrome - 1805 Points

3. V8 Benchmark Suite - version 3: http://v8.googlecode.com/svn/data/bench ... 3/run.html (viac = rychlejsi)

IE 7.0.5730.13 - Score: 23,3 poinst (vyskocila hlaska, pre ukoncenie skriptu)
Firefox 3.5.3 - Score: 182 poinst
Google Chrome - Score: 1705 poinst


kazdy test som spravil 2x a vysledky spriemeroval. Spravil som to len preto, ze som sa pekelne nudil a chcel som vidiet rozdiel medzi novym Google Chrome a Firefox 3.5.3